Home » Blog » "SiCKO": A Call to Action

Blog for America

"SiCKO": A Call to Action

Written by: Maureen Stabile on Jul 11, 2007 7:50 AM EDT

Linked to groups: Hanover Township Democrats & Independents (HanDI)

"What do we do now?"

We sat at a table cluttered with empty coffee cups, crumpled napkins and crumb-filled plates. Although the showing of "SiCKO" had ended nearly two hours before, the dozen-plus members of our party had lingered at the nearby pancake house to discuss the movie, a satirical documentary about the U.S. health care debacle. Of all the comments offered over the course of our late-night meal, that simple question, posed by a HanDI friend from Barrington, has stood out most prominently to me: "What do we do now?"

In the week-and-a-half since then, I have heard echoes of that question in other blog entries, in conversations with friends, and at our HanDI members' meeting on Monday. Of course, we already took a small step by distributing nearly 100 flyers with information about health care and HanDI at the AMC South Barrington following our showing of "SiCKO." And now thanks to luck, a little curiosity and the wisdom of others, I have found further resources for learning and activism that I share in my next blog entry. First, a few more words about why change is necessary.

Let's agree that the current system is just not working. In his film, Michael Moore wisely focused not on Americans who lack health insurance, but on those who do have it and still suffer. The point made is that for-profit health insurance *is* the problem. Health should not be a commodity to be bought and sold. It is a fundamental human right, like education, public safety and free speech. The United States spends more per person on health care than any other country in the world, and we have by far the poorest outcomes of any industrialized nation. The only beneficiaries of this wasted investment are the insurance company executives and their stockholders.

Can the system be changed? There is hope. Lending libraries, public schools and even municipal police forces are relatively recent inventions in human history, and now most Americans don’t question the necessity of sharing the costs for these public services. There was also a time, not so long ago, when most Americans believed that child labor, illiteracy, and the disfranchisement of females and blacks were enduring and unchangeable aspects of life -- just part of "the way things are." Those benighted days, which fell within the lifetime of some fellow citizens who are still with us, seem very far away. But the social and legal innovations that have so greatly improved our collective lot didn’t just "happen," and they were certainly not created through the beneficence of the business sector. Change that benefits the whole of society requires a mass movement with visionary leadership. Fortunately, those leaders are here now. Will we answer their call?

Tags:

Discuss
 

Reply

Default_user

-

By sidney moss on Jul 11, 2007 5:40 PM EDT

  We need a single payer plan --why not start with the need to support SCHIPS the plan that the Children's Defense  Fund supports. Check out  their ad in the  NY Times op ed section, July 10th.  Shows a 14 year old boy who died after being denied  treatment.  We need to have a helath plan that is  truly concerned  to provide  caring  life saving  treatment for all. Sicko provides vivid examples  of   them kind of compassionate health care. we shouild strive for

.

Default_user

-

By Wayne Dickson on Jul 22, 2007 5:31 PM EDT

I heard an NPR interview the other day with a guy who is, as I recall, an associate professor in public health? from University of Maryland. (Could be wrong about the details, but not the substance). Associate professor means the guy has meaningful publishing cred but isn't (yet?) a superstar. He talked about present dismal reality, future possibility, and ways to negotiate the distance between. He said that, in his opinion, the most politically feasible way forward for the U.S. is the Australian model, which is apparently a public-private hybrid. I'll research it. Meantime, I hope experts will chip in to enlighten "the rest of us."

T205203

-

By Robert Field on Jul 23, 2007 7:34 AM EDT

Only A Push For Fundmamental Change Will Work.

I agree that SCHIP is, in itself, worth saving and that it is keeping children alive. What bothers me, though, is that the tendency toward incremental change is used to convince Americans that fundamental change isn't necessary. After all, 18,000 Americans were dying every year from inadequate health care while SCHIP was fully funded.

When we look at a program like SCHIP, we should be asking ourselves what is stopping us from agitating effectively for fundamental reform in how we treat our citizens. Even groups like DFA, which I have participated in for years, resort to organizing letter-writing campaigns to Congress and other appeals to our leadership.

But the reason our leaders resist the fundamental reforms that America requires is fear of the vested interests determined to condemn their fellow citizens to misery and death for profit. Only by making them more afraid of us than they are of them can we inspire American politicians to stop offering crumbs, smoke, and mirrors, and solve these problems.

We have to organize for a big push. And if our goal is single-payer, that means we have to shoot higher, for a non-profit system. Then we can compromise our way down to a Canadian-style system, which is the bare minumum required to address the problem.

We have to camp on doorsteps, be continuous presence in the lives of our representatives. We have to be more omnipresent than insurance industry lobbyists.

Add your comment

(to reply directly to a comment, click the reply icon for that comment)

Post closed to commenting

Videos of some of the 64 House Healthcare Heroes standing strong for a public health insurance option

Congressman Emanuel Cleaver



Congressman Lloyd Dogget



Congressman Keith Ellison



Congressman Bob Filner



Congressman Phil Hare



Congresswoman Lynn Woolsey



Congresswoman Maxine Waters

Blog for America

Recent Blog Posts

The Watercooler